Supreme Court of India acquits Birka Shiva of rape and kidnapping charges on July 16, 2025.
CASE SUMMARY – In Birka Shiva vs. State of Telangana, the Supreme Court overturned the appellant’s conviction under IPC Sections 376, 363, and 342. The victim allegedly lived with the accused for two months, but the prosecution failed to establish she was a minor or that her consent was absent. Her testimony lacked consistency, and the birth certificate was deemed uncorroborated. There was no credible evidence of coercion or confinement. The Court held that guilt could not be inferred from assumptions, emphasizing the need for concrete proof. On July 17, 2025, the Court acquitted Birka Shiva, reversing the previous convictions.
SC ACQUITS BIRKA SHIVA IN RAPE AND KIDNAPPING CASE DUE TO LACK OF EVIDENCE
| ASPECTS | DETAILS |
| Case Title | Birka Shiva vs. State of Telangana |
| Introduction | Appeal against conviction under IPC Sections 376, 363, and 342. Trial and High Court convicted; Supreme Court overturned due to lack of evidence on age, consent, and confinement. |
| Factual Background | Victim allegedly kidnapped and confined for two months, sexually assaulted. Age was disputed. FIR filed days later; evidence was circumstantial and uncorroborated. |
| Legal Issues |
|
| Applicable Law |
|
| Analysis | Ex.P11 (birth certificate) lacked corroboration. No medical or testimonial proof of force. Victim accompanied accused voluntarily and lived with him without restraint. |
| Conclusion | Prosecution failed to prove essential elements. Age of victim uncertain, no evidence of confinement or non-consensual intercourse. Supreme Court acquitted appellant. |
| Current Scenario | As of July 17, 2025, Supreme Court judgment acquits Birka Shiva of all charges. Previous convictions by Trial and High Court set aside. |
SC ACQUITS BIRKA SHIVA IN RAPE AND KIDNAPPING CASE DUE TO LACK OF EVIDENCE
“Courts of law cannot make a determination of guilt in thin air, based on estimations.”
SOURCE – SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
READ ALSO – Indian Penal Code: Sections 376 (Rape), 363 (Kidnapping), 342 (Confinement);
