The Supreme Court reaffirms that narco-analysis without consent violates fundamental rights.
SUPREME COURT QUASHES NARCO-ANALYSIS ORDER IN AMLLESH KUMAR CASE
CASE SUMMARY – The Supreme Court in Amlesh Kumar vs State of Bihar quashed a Patna High Court order permitting narco-analysis of accused in a dowry-related disappearance case . The Court held that such involuntary tests violate Articles 20(3) and 21, reaffirming the precedent set in Selvi v. State of Karnataka. It clarified that voluntary narco tests are not admissible unless corroborated and cannot be claimed as a right . The judgment emphasized that bail hearings should not entertain such invasive measures . The appeal was allowed, and the High Court’s order set aside, safeguarding constitutional protections of accused persons in criminal investigations .
SUPREME COURT QUASHES NARCO-ANALYSIS ORDER IN AMLLESH KUMAR CASE
| ASPECTS | DETAILS |
| Case Title | Amlesh Kumar vs The State of Bihar |
| Introduction | Appeal against Patna High Court’s order allowing narco-analysis test of accused, which was challenged as unconstitutional. |
| Factual Background | FIR lodged on 24 Aug 2022 alleging dowry and disappearance of appellant’s wife; High Court permitted narco-analysis tests during bail hearing. |
| Legal Issues |
|
| Applicable Law | Article 20(3), Article 21 of the Constitution of India; Section 27 of Indian Evidence Act; Section 439 CrPC. |
| Analysis | Court relied on Selvi v. State of Karnataka (2010) to emphasize that involuntary narco tests violate fundamental rights; voluntary test results are inadmissible without corroboration. |
| Conclusion | High Court erred in allowing test; order quashed; narco-analysis cannot be forced nor claimed as an absolute right. |
| Current Scenario | Bail application to be decided afresh as per law; judgment reinforces rights against self-incrimination. |
“No individual should be forcibly subjected to narco-analysis or similar techniques—doing so amounts to an unwarranted intrusion into personal liberty.”
SOURCE – SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
READ ALSO – Article 21 of the Constitution of India
