Headline
The order of the High Court was set aside by The Supreme Court of India for absence of reasoning and remands the case for fresh hearing.
Summary
The Supreme Court of India overturned a Division Bench decision of the High Court for lack of proper reasoning in its judgment.The Supreme Court remanded the case back to the High Court for a fresh new hearing, stressing the need of reasoned judgments for gaining public trust in the judicial process.
Key Facts
- Case Name: State Project Director, UP Education for All Project Board & Ors. vs. Saroj Maurya & Ors., Civil Appeal No. 3465 of 2023.
- Name of Judges:Justice Hima Kohli and Justice Sandeep Mehta.
- The Supreme Court of India found that the High Court’s Division Bench had made a mistake by upholding a Single Judge’s decision without giving any reasons, disregarding government orders which were relevant to the case.
Legal Insights
The Supreme Court of India showcased the significance of reasoned judgments, citing the precedent set in ‘CCT v. Shukla & Bros. (2010)’. It emphasized that a reasoned judgment is very important for transparency and accountability in the judicial process.
Impact
The Supreme Court of India focused on the need for thorough and reasoned judgments, making sure that appellate courts have a clear understanding of the reasons given by the lower court, which is important for fair adjudication.
Why It Matters
It highlights the Supreme Court’s commitment to upholding the rule of law by making it sure that all judicial orders are properly reasoned, thereby maintaining trust in the legal system.
Source:
