Headline
The Supreme Court of India showed concerns over the senior advocate designation system and referred the matter to CJI.
Summary
The Supreme Court of India has shown concerns over the process of Senior Advocate designation under the case of Indira Jaising (2017 & 2023), questioning aspects like self-application, interview-based assessment, and a rigid points-based system. A bench of Justices Abhay S Oka and Augustine George Masih has referred the case to the Chief Justice of India for reconsideration by a larger bench.
Key Facts
- Case Name: Jitender @ Kalla vs. State (Govt.) of NCT of Delhi & Anr.,
- Bench: Justice Abhay Oka, Justice Augustine George Masih
- The Court questioned the fairness of self-application for Senior Advocate designation, weightage was given to interviews, and the mechanical allocation of points without considering active legal practice.
- The lack of provisions to account for an advocate’s integrity and fairness in the evaluation process was flagged.
- The process may disadvantage lawyers of trial court who lack reported judgments but possess strong legal standing.
- The court ordered the Registrar General to place the judgment before the CJI.
Legal Insights
- Section 16(2) of the Advocates Act suggests that the designation of a Senior Advocate is a privilege, not a right.
- The Supreme Court of India questioned whether brief interviews could assess reliably on the merits of an advocate.
- The prohibition on secret ballot voting was challenged, with few advising its reintroduction for transparency.
- The case also discussed the responsibilities of Advocates-on-Record (AoR), regarding the false statements made in pleas of remission by Senior Advocate Rishi Malhotra.
Impact
- The decision could lead to a major revision of the Senior Advocate designation process.
- It may redefine Advocates-on-Record (AoR) responsibilities to control misrepresentations in legal filings.
- If a larger bench is made, it could introduce new criteria for evaluating competence of advocates’ and integrity.
Why It Matters
The Senior Advocate designation holds important prestige in the legal profession. The concern of a Court shows the requirement for a more transparent and merit-based selection process, ensuring that only the most deserving advocates receive this honor.
Source:
Read also– JUSTICE SANJIV KHANNA APPOINTED NEW CJI
