EVOLUTION OF JUSTICE: INTEGRATING AI IN JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS

by | Apr 14, 2024

The intersection of technology and law has always been a fascinating arena, and today, it stands at a pivotal moment with the advent of artificial intelligence (AI). Chief Justice of India, D.Y. Chandrachud, recently emphasized the inevitability of integrating AI into the judicial system during the Indo-Singapore Judicial Conference. This heralds a new chapter in the pursuit of justice, one marked by the promise and challenges posed by technological advancement. As the legal landscape evolves, the integration of AI brings both opportunities and complexities to the forefront, reshaping how justice is delivered and accessed.

Background

The judiciary’s adoption of technology isn’t new, but the pace at which it’s evolving is remarkable. From digitizing case records to the implementation of e-filing systems, courts worldwide have embraced technology to enhance efficiency and accessibility. However, the introduction of AI introduces a paradigm shift, raising complex questions about ethics, legality, and practicality.

Key Aspects

Hybrid-Mode Hearings:

    • Breaking Geographical Barriers: Hybrid-mode hearings transcend physical boundaries, enabling lawyers from any part of the country to represent clients before the highest court without the constraints of travel and expense.
    • Democratizing Access to Justice: By eliminating the need for expensive and time-consuming travel to the capital, hybrid-mode hearings democratize access to the Supreme Court of India, ensuring that justice is not limited by geographical location.
    • Nationwide Representation: This innovation allows for nationwide representation, empowering lawyers to advocate for their clients irrespective of their location, thus promoting inclusivity and equal access to justice.

AI-Powered Transcription Services:

      • Real-Time Translation: AI-powered transcription services offer real-time translation of judicial proceedings into regional languages, ensuring that legal information is accessible to all citizens, regardless of their linguistic background.
      • Inclusivity and Accessibility: By providing accurate and timely translations, these services enhance inclusivity and accessibility within the judicial system, enabling a diverse range of individuals to participate effectively in legal proceedings.
      • Enhanced Understanding: The availability of translations in multiple languages enhances understanding and comprehension, thereby facilitating fair and transparent justice delivery.

CJI’s Remarks:

      • Double-Edged Sword: Chief Justice Chandrachud characterizes AI as a double-edged sword, acknowledging its potential to either enhance or undermine the pursuit of justice, depending on how it is utilized within the judicial system.
      • Recognition of Potential Impact: His remarks underscore the importance of recognizing the potential impact of AI on the legal profession, urging stakeholders to engage in nuanced deliberations to ensure that the integration of AI aligns with the principles of fairness, transparency, and equality.
      • Advocacy for Technological Evolution: Despite the challenges posed by AI, Chief Justice Chandrachud advocates for embracing technological evolution within the legal profession, emphasizing the need to adapt to advancements in order to streamline processes and enhance efficiency.

Future Scope:

        • Expedited Processes: The integration of AI has the potential to expedite judicial processes, leading to faster resolution of cases and reduced backlog, thus improving overall efficiency within the legal system.
        • Predictive Analytics and Research Tools: AI-powered predictive analytics and research tools hold promise for assisting legal professionals in case management, legal research, and decision-making, thereby enhancing the quality and effectiveness of legal services.
        • Ethical and Legal Implications: However, the future scope of AI in the judicial system also necessitates careful consideration of ethical and legal implications, including concerns related to data privacy, algorithmic bias, and the equitable distribution of technological resources.

Legal Aspects: Pros and Cons:

            • Pros: The integration of AI has the potential to improve efficiency, reduce backlog, and increase access to justice, thus benefiting both legal professionals and citizens seeking legal recourse.
            • Cons: However, there are concerns about potential risks associated with AI, including issues related to data privacy, algorithmic bias, and the exacerbation of inequalities due to differential access to technology.

Recent Developments

The Law Minister’s emphasis on adopting ML and AI technologies underscores the need for modernization in the justice delivery system. The Supreme Court’s formation of an Artificial Intelligence Committee highlights the exploration of AI applications in translation, legal research, and process automation.

Topic Description
Recent Developments Law Minister advocates for ML and AI in justice delivery.

Supreme Court forms AI Committee to explore AI applications

eCourts Project – Aims to ICT-enable courts across India.

Monitored and funded by Department of Justice.

Objectives: Efficiency, citizen-centric services, decision support, transparency

Need for Technology in Judiciary High number of pending cases necessitates technological intervention.

Virtual hearings and AI-driven solutions like SUVAS (Supreme Court Vidhik Anuvaad Software) and SUPACE (Supreme Court Portal for Assistance in Court Efficiency)

Examples of Technology Use
  • Virtual hearings facilitated by technology during pandemic.
  • SUVAS translates judgments into regional languages.
  • SUPACE automates judicial processes using AI
Similar Global Initiatives Various countries implementing AI tools like COMPAS, HART, and robot judges for tasks such as risk assessment and document management
Possible Uses of AI & ML Expedite trials, assist in analyzing precedents, create ‘judge analytics’ for informed decision-making
Understanding AI and ML AI: Machines perform tasks requiring human intelligence

ML: Software predicts outcomes based on historical data

Guiding Principles Upholding principles of fairness, transparency, and accessibility.

Ensuring responsible integration of AI and ML technologies

Key Takeaways AI and ML hold promise for enhancing efficiency and accessibility in justice delivery.

Ethical and regulatory considerations are crucial for responsible implementation

 

In summary, the key aspects highlighted underscore the transformative potential of AI in the judicial system, while also emphasizing the importance of addressing associated challenges in order to ensure that the integration of AI aligns with the principles of fairness, transparency, and accessibility in the administration of justice.

 

Source- The Hindu

Also Read- DELHI HIGH COURT DISMISSES PLEA AGAINST ARVIND KEJRIWAL’S REMOVAL AS CHIEF MINISTER

 

 

Written By Vishakha Khatri

My name is Vishakha Khatri. I am an engineering graduate and a civil service aspirant with a passion for spreading knowledge about Indian polity. I believe that understanding our political system is crucial for every citizen, and I am committed to making this information accessible to everyone in my own easy way. Through my experiences in civil service preparation and my unique perspective as an engineering graduate, I hope to inspire and educate others on the importance of Indian polity.

Related Posts

RIGHT TO VOTE

RIGHT TO VOTE

Introduction The right to vote is a fundamental right in any democratic society, ensuring that citizens have a say in who governs them and how they are...

CUSTODIAL DEATH

CUSTODIAL DEATH

Custodial deaths, a grim reality in India, have seen a startling increase over the last few years, raising serious concerns about human rights violations and...

BAIL

BAIL

Bail, an integral facet of criminal justice systems worldwide, embodies the intricate balance between individual liberty and societal interests. In recent...