DOWER/MEHR UNDER MUSLIM LAW
Dower, under Muslim law, is known as ‘Mahr.’ It represents a monetary obligation that the husband undertakes to pay to the wife upon marriage. This article delves into the historical roots and the intricate details of mahr under Muslim law. In Arabic, ‘Mahr’ literally means Dower. It is a monetary sum payable by the husband to the wife upon marriage. Mahr is established either through mutual agreement or by operation of law. Various jurists, including Wilson, Mulla, and Ameer Ali, have attempted to define mahr, viewing it as a form of consideration or obligation belonging to the wife.
SECULARISM AND PERSONAL LAWS IN INDIA
India stands as a secular country, where the state is not aligned with any specific religion. This secular ethos is enshrined in the Constitution, which guarantees freedom of conscience and the right to profess, practice, and propagate religion for every individual. This inclusive approach leads to the existence of different personal laws based on religion. While various communities have their distinct personal laws, Muslims, in general, are governed by Muslim personal law, encompassing aspects such as marriage, dower, divorce, will, and maintenance.
HISTORICAL EVOLUTION OF MAHR
- Pre-Islamic Arabia
In the pre-Islamic era, marriage customs in Arabia differed significantly from contemporary practices. A lack of legal structures led to various forms of sexual relationships, often leaving women as victims of abuse. The Shighar form of marriage involved reciprocal arrangements, and in the Beena marriage, a gift called Sadaq was given to the wife. The ancient Baal marriage introduced the concept of mahr, a form of compensation for the wife’s parents or guardians.
- Islam’s Influence
The advent of Islam brought about a transformation in marriage practices. Islamic teachings emphasized generosity upon separation and forbade the reclaiming of goods given to the wife. This marked the origin of the concept of husbands providing financial support to their wives on marriage, formalized as mahr under Islamic law.
CONSIDERATION IN CONTRACT VS. CONSIDERATION IN MUSLIM LAW
The term ‘consideration’ in Muslim law takes on a distinct meaning from its contractual counterpart. While the absence of consideration in a contract renders it void, the lack of explicit mention of dower or consideration during Muslim marriage does not invalidate it. Islamic law emphasizes the husband’s obligation to provide dower as a mark of respect for the wife.
DOWER VS. DOWRY: A DISTINCT DICHOTOMY
The literal meaning of ‘mahr’ is dower, setting it apart from dowry. Mahr, in Muslim law, serves to ensure women’s financial security, while dowry is viewed as a social evil. Dowry involves gifts from the bride’s family to the groom’s kin and is explicitly addressed in Indian law through the Dowry Prohibition Act of 1961.
CLASSIFICATION OF DOWER
Dower in Muslim law can be categorized into specified dower, prompt dower, deferred dower, and proper or customary dower.
- Specified Dower
– The amount is stated in the marriage contract.
– It may be settled before, during, or after the marriage.
– The guardian can fix the dower amount for a minor or lunatic boy.
– There are minimum amounts set by various schools of Islamic law.
– Payable immediately after marriage upon demand.
- Deferred Dower
– Paid after marriage dissolution, either by death or divorce.
- Proper or Customary Dower
– Applicable when the marriage lacks a specified dower amount.
– Determined by considering various factors such as the wife’s personal qualifications, social position, economic conditions of the husband, and circumstances of time.
ADDRESSING CHALLENGES: LOW INTENTIONAL DOWER
In certain cases, husbands intentionally provide a low amount of dower, rendering it insufficient for the wife’s maintenance. Legislation intervenes to ensure a reasonable dower, empowering the court to determine an appropriate amount irrespective of the marriage deed.
RIGHTS OF THE WIFE REGARDING DOWER
Under Muslim law, a wife has legal remedies if her right to dower is violated:
- Refusal to Cohabit:
– If the marriage is unconsummated, the wife can refuse cohabitation until the prompt dower is paid.
– A guardian can refuse to send a minor or insane wife to her husband’s house until the prompt dower is given.
- Consummated Marriage
– If consummation has occurred, the wife loses the absolute right to insist on the prompt dower.
– The husband can file a suit for restitution of conjugal rights, and the wife is entitled to a conditional payment of dower.
- Deferred Dower
– Opinions vary on whether a wife can refuse to cohabit in cases of unpaid deferred dower.
DOWER AS A DEBT
According to the Privy Council, dower ranks as a debt. The widow can claim it on her husband’s death, and if the husband is alive, the wife can recover the dower through legal action. Unpaid dower debt can be enforced against the husband’s heirs.
RETENTION OF POSSESSION IN LIEU OF UNPAID DOWER
While dower ranks as a debt, the wife is entitled to retain possession of her husband’s estate until her dower claim is satisfied. However, this right does not grant ownership, and the widow cannot alienate the property.
EFFECT OF APOSTASY ON DOWER
Apostasy, the abandonment of Islam, impacts Muslim personal law significantly. While a man’s apostasy can lead to the immediate dissolution of marriage, a woman’s apostasy does not automatically dissolve the marriage. The Dissolution of Muslim Marriage Act of 1939 protects a married Muslim woman’s right to dower even after apostasy.
LEGAL RECOURSE: SUIT FOR DOWER AND LIMITATION
If dower is not paid during the wife’s lifetime, her heirs can claim it after her death. The Limitation Act of 1963 sets a three-year period for a suit to recover prompt dower from the date of demand or refusal. In the case of deferred dower, the limitation period is three years from the date of marriage dissolution.
CONCLUSION:
The concept of Mahr under Muslim Law holds immense significance for women. It serves as a safeguard, ensuring financial security and preventing vulnerability after the death of the husband or marriage termination. Beyond its legal implications, mahr is a pivotal custom in Muslim marriages, reflecting the respect and financial responsibility inherent in the marital relationship.
REFERENCE
